Skip to content
MLS

MLS playoff notebook: Breaking down everything from Saturday’s Round 1 slate

We're breaking down each and every game of the MLS postseason. Here's how Saturday's slate of Round 1 matches were won and lost.

New England Revolution

Here at Backheeled, we're breaking down each and every game of the MLS postseason with the updating notebook. Check back here throughout the next month to see how the latest playoff matches were won and lost!


MLS playoff notebook: How FC Cincinnati, Real Salt Lake triumphed in the wildcard round
We're breaking down each and every game of the MLS postseason. Here's how the wildcard matches were won and lost.

Game 1: Inter Miami 0-3 Columbus Crew

What we learned about Miami: Miami are not a good team at this point of the season. 

They’re an unorganized and chaotic collection of talent at various stages of degradation, and they’ve papered over the cracks with the best player in the history of the game, whose individual brilliance is no longer enough to make up for a genuinely disastrous back line. In retrospect, Javier Mascherano deserves infinitely more credit than he gets for making them a functional team during their run to MLS Cup.

Maybe we shouldn’t be surprised by how abjectly awful they were against Columbus. The Crew were the hottest team in MLS heading into the playoffs, Miami have only won six matches at home this season, and haven’t beaten a playoff team since July 25. I’m certainly not surprised they lost – I picked them to crash out in the first round. 

But, man, seeing the Crew carve the Herons apart from the opening whistle was jarring.

Even before Luján's red card, Columbus were carving Miami apart.

— Ben Wright (@benwright.bsky.social) 2026-11-22T00:37:02.625Z

It was bad with 11 men. It got even worse once Gonzalo Luján got sent off for an objectively stupid tackle. Lionel Messi flirted with a red card of his own, and was held in check for the full second half. 

This post is for paid subscribers

Subscribe

Already have an account? Log in