Skip to content
MLS

Hater’s Guide to the 2026 MLS playoffs: Why each team won’t win MLS Cup

Your favorite team? They'll crush your hopes. At least we're letting you down easy...

Design: Peyton Gallaher

Somebody’s gotta do it, right? 

Somebody has to shake you free from the entirely too optimistic feeling that accompanies the little gap between MLS Decision Day and the start of the playoffs — and Backheeled is stepping up to the plate, just like we do every year.

Look, we don’t really hate your team. Here at Backheeled, we love your team. And we love you. And we want you and your team to be happy and win things and be better than everyone else and live forever and ever and ever. But consider this preparation for the inevitable sadness that will set in for sympathetic viewers of the 17 postseason teams that won’t be lifting MLS Cup on Friday, December 18th.

Sure, one team will win the darn thing, but we're just playing the odds here, people. We're guarding your heart so you don’t have to. You’re welcome.

Now, onwards to the Haterade cooler, starting with the East and working our way West. Here’s why your team won’t win MLS Cup.

Nashville SC, 1st in the East

Why they won’t win: Because they can be pressed out of a game

There’s a whole lot to like about Nashville SC, with match-winning talent in every line of the field and goalkeeper Brian Schwake having one of the best shot-stopping seasons in recorded MLS history. This team just set the single-season points record, for crying out loud. Still: this is MLS. Everybody has a flaw — and perhaps Nashville’s biggest is playing through a tight, man-to-man press.

Star striker Sam Surridge is excellent at many things, but there’s a reason why BJ Callaghan opted to shift from using the Englishman as a lone No. 9 to using him as part of a front two in a 4-2-2-2 possession setup. Surridge isn’t an outlet: he ranks in just the 49th percentile among strikers in MLS for aerial duel win rate, as per FotMob. Add in the fact that the rest of Nashville’s front four would often rather receive the ball to feet rather than run in behind and Nashville SC, when faced with an aggressive press, can find themselves pinned in.

Of course, pressing Nashville is still a major risk. They have plenty of players who can pick out a pass and plenty more who can beat their man on the ball. But forcing the Supporters’ Shield winners to play long is the best way to get at them.

Inter Miami, 2nd in the East

Why they won’t win: Because this team isn’t like the one that lifted MLS Cup last year

This post is for paid subscribers

Subscribe

Already have an account? Log in